Discover Top 7 Mouthwatering Seaside Heights Pizza Joints

If you’re in the midst of planning a trip to Seaside Heights, one question may be lingering in your mind: where can you find the best Seaside Heights pizza? After all, there’s nothing quite like sinking your teeth into a hot and savory slice after a long day spent soaking up the sun on the beach or enjoying the sights and sounds of the lively boardwalk.

But with so many Seaside Heights pizza places to choose from, it can be overwhelming to know where to start your search. Fear not, we’re here to guide you through the maze of options and help you discover the perfect slice to satisfy your cravings. Get ready to tantalize your taste buds with some of the most mouthwatering pizza Seaside Heights has to offer!

Top 7 Seaside Heights Pizza Joints

Three Brothers From Italy

Three Brothers from Italy Pizza is, an iconic Seaside Heights pizza spot on the Boardwalk, has been delighting customers for decades. With three locations, two in Seaside Heights and one in the Park, they offer a wide range of pizza options to suit every taste. From classic margherita and pepperoni to specialty pies with unique toppings, their crispy crust is consistently praised. Their fries are another standout feature that customers love.

Maruca’s Tomato Pies

For pizza enthusiasts on the Boardwalk, Maruca’s Tomato Pies has been a cherished destination since the 1950s. Founded by four brothers and still family-owned, this pizzeria stands out with its exclusive cheese blend, melted onto a thin and crispy crust. The signature touch of their local Jersey tomato sauce swirled on top, adds an irresistible flavor. Maruca’s is the only Seaside Heights pizza spot that has gained recognition through appearances on popular food shows like Man vs Food and Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives. For all you planners and line haters out there, they offer online ordering for easy pickup.

The Sawmill

Since the 1970s, The Sawmill has been a staple on the Seaside Park Boardwalk. Its humble beginnings as a hot dog stand near Funtown Pier’s Log Flume inspired its unique name. Today, you have the choice to order at their convenient walk up window or enjoy a sit down experience inside the restaurant. Alongside their iconic jumbo pizza slices, The Sawmill offers a variety of other delectable options to satisfy your cravings.

Little Mia’s

Little Mia’s Pizza, a delightful addition to the Seaside Heights pizza scene, has quickly captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Nestled on the vibrant Boulevard, this charming pizzeria stands out with its moderate prices, making it a refreshing choice compared to its Boardwalk competitors. Little Mia’s offers typical portions and prices that you are used to. They are known for great gluten free pizza options, and you can also order online.

DJs Italian Hotdogs & Sausage House Pizzeria

DJs is like hitting the jackpot when it comes to food and pizza on the boardwalk! Not only do their dishes receive top notch ratings from customers, but their prices won’t make your wallet cry out for help either. And guess what? They even serve breakfast!

But hold on, the awesomeness doesn’t stop there. The DJ’s is very friendly and the owner is usually there. You’ll spot the staff bustling around, making sure everything is clean. This Seaside Heights pizza place is a must try.

Klee’s Bar & Grill

Klee’s Bar and Grill is the quintessential neighborhood hangout, where you can indulge in a delectable bar pie that’s sure to satisfy your pizza cravings. Unlike the oversized slices found on the Boardwalk, Klee’s is known for their thin crispy crust.

At Klee’s, you’ll discover a variety of specialty pizza options to delight your taste buds. Take, for instance, their Tuscany pizza, featuring a combination of eggplant, sun dried tomatoes, garlic, velvety vodka sauce, and a generous layer of gooey mozzarella cheese. It’s a flavor explosion that transports you to the heart of Italy. If you’re in the mood for something truly unique, The Dupont is a must try. This captivating white pie showcases a luscious blend of olive oil, vibrant broccoli, delicate spinach, creamy mozzarella cheese, and velvety ricotta. Every bite is a harmonious symphony of flavors that will leave you craving more.

Shore Slice Pizza & Grill

Located on the north end of the Boardwalk, Shore Slice Pizza Grill has a dedicated following. When it comes to size, Shore Slice caters to both the hungry and the ravenous. Choose between their classic large, thin square pizzas that deliver a satisfying crunch with each bite, or opt for the extra large option that promises an abundance of cheesy goodness to satiate even the heartiest appetites.

This Seaside Heights pizza joint also offer specialty options. For a taste of fiery excitement, look no further than the Jersey Devil pizza. With a zesty marinara base, the perfect amount of heat from hot cherry peppers, delectable pepperoni, basil, and a sprinkling of shaved Parmesan. It’s a flavor packed experience that will leave you craving more.

If you’re a fan of the classic buffalo chicken flavor, Shore Slice has you covered with their mouthwatering Buffalo chicken pizza. Chicken mingles with a tangy hot sauce, all crowned with a cool ranch drizzle.

To make your experience even more convenient, Shore Slice offers online ordering with a special discount on your entire order.

You Vote! Who Has The Best Pizza in Seaside Heights?

Where is the best pizza in Seaside Heights?

What is your favorite topping?

What is your favorite type of pizza?

Why does New York pizza dough taste so good?

The thin, crispy crust and deliciously chewy texture of New York style pizza have made it a fan favorite around the world. One of the key reasons for the dough’s irresistible flavor is the quality of the ingredients used in its preparation. Many New York pizzerias opt for high gluten flour, which results in a dough that’s stretchy.

Another factor that contributes to the unique taste and texture of New York style pizza dough is the mineral content of the city’s tap water. Finally, the high heat of the pizza oven plays a critical role in achieving the perfect crispy crust that’s synonymous with New York style pizza. When combined, these factors create a truly mouth watering culinary experience that’s hard to beat.

Why are Jersey Shore pizza slices so big?

If you’ve ever visited the Jersey Shore, you may have noticed that the pizza slices are much larger than those you’d typically find in other areas. The Jersey Shore has long been a popular destination for tourists and beachgoers. Pizzerias have capitalized on this by offering slices that are big enough to satisfy even the heartiest of appetites.

Additionally, the competition between pizzerias at the Shore is fierce, and offering larger slices has become a way to stand out from the crowd and attract customers. Whatever the reason, one thing is for certain: when it comes to Seaside Heights pizza, bigger is definitely better!

Why do some people call pizza a pie?

One of the most enduring nicknames for pizza is “pie”. One theory is that the term “pie” originally referred to any kind of baked dish with a filling, including both sweet and savory dishes. Since pizza fits this description, it’s possible that early American pizzerias simply adopted the term “pie” to describe pizza.

Pizza has become one of the most beloved foods in the world. Originating in Italy, pizza has since spread across the globe, taking on new and exciting forms as it’s adapted to local cultures and tastes. From classic margherita to loaded meat lovers’ pies, there are countless types of pizza out there to satisfy any craving.

Whether you’re a die hard traditionalist or a fan of experimental toppings, there’s a pizza out there for everyone. So, let’s explore the wide and wonderful world of pizza and discover some of the most delicious and unique varieties out there. Be sure to be on the look out for each as you explore Seaside Heights pizza.

New York vs Chicago Pizza

Most Seaside Heights pizza is going to be New York style. The rivalry between New York style and Chicago style pizza is a long and passionate one. These two styles both have distinct features and dedicated fan bases.

New York style pizza has thin, wide, and easily foldable slices. Its trademark thin and crispy crust is chewy at the same time. Toppings are layered on top of the cheese, producing a harmonious fusion of flavors. New York style pizza thrives on simplicity, allowing the quality ingredients to shine through.

In contrast, Chicago style pizza is famous for its deep dish, pie like structure. The thick and buttery crust serves as a robust foundation for generous layers of cheese, toppings, and chunky tomato sauce. Eaten with a knife and fork, Chicago style pizza is a hearty and indulgent delight, with its depth of flavors and textures.

Grandma Pizza

Ah, Grandma Pizza, the culinary delight that’s like a warm hug from your favorite nonna! Picture this: a square-shaped pizza with a thick, fluffy, and slightly crispy crust that’s made with love. It’s not too thick like its deep-dish cousins, nor too thin like the New York-style slices. Grandma Pizza finds that perfect balance, just like the wise and experienced grandma it’s named after.

What sets Grandma Pizza apart is its simplicity. The toppings are minimal but oh-so-flavorful. You’ll find a rich tomato sauce, often made from scratch with a hint of garlic and herbs, spreading its deliciousness across the canvas of dough. A generous sprinkle of mozzarella cheese is there to provide that gooey, melty goodness we all crave.

Neapolitan Pizza

Originating in Naples, Italy, this pizza style has it’s own certification process and is known for its simplicity. The ingredients used are carefully selected and must meet specific criteria. For the tomatoes, it’s either San Marzano tomatoes or Pomodorino del Piennolo del Vesuvio, while the cheese must be Mozzarella di Bufala Campana. The dough is made from brewer’s yeast, salt, and water, and must be hand kneaded and no thicker than a few millimeters. Toppings? Absolutely none allowed!

A beloved variation that does not adhere to these strict guidelines is often known as Margherita pizza. This delightful creation showcases a topping combination of tomato, mozzarella, basil, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil , sometimes accompanied by a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese. The thin and soft crust is cooked at a high temperature, resulting in delightful bubbles and charred spots that add to its distinctive flavor. While you are unlikely to find a Seaside Heights pizza spot that offers a certified Neapolitan pizza, you will find plenty that offer Margherita pizza.

Sicilian Pizza

Sicilian Pizza
Photo by Parker Hilton on Unsplash

The original, authentic version of this pizza comes Palermo Sicily. It is called sfincione, which loosely translates as “thick sponge.” Thick spongy dough is prepared from a combination of flour, water, olive oil, and yeast and is pressed into a square pan.

Sicilian pizza is topped with a sauce made from tomatoes, onions, herbs, and anchovies. It is then is covered with breadcrumbs and an optional grating of hard cheese, never mozzarella. While cooking, the olive oil in the pan is absorbed, resulting in the bottom of the pizza to become crisp, while the middle portion remains soft. You will definitely be able to find Seaside Heights pizza options for this style of pizza

Detroit Style Pizza

Originating from the 1940s, Detroit style pizza has recently surged in national popularity. This unique style draws inspiration from Sicilian pizza while adding its own twist. The dough takes center stage, undergoing a double proofing process that ensures optimal texture and taste.

What sets Detroit style pizza apart is the placement of the pepperoni and the unique cheese. The pepperoni is pressed into the dough, allowing the richness of the meat to infuse into the crust. The Wisconsin brick cheese, which is known for its nutty undertones, rich creaminess, and delightful tanginess is then crumbled on top extending right up to the edges. As it bakes, it caramelizes against the high sided heavyweight rectangular pan, creating a delectable crust that’s crispy on the outside and delightfully soft on the inside.

Detroit style pizzas were originally baked in rectangular steel trays, repurposed from automotive drip pans. These unconventional pans were used due to the lack of specialized baking pans at the time, and they inadvertently contributed to the unique character of pizza.

California Style Pizza

California Style Pizza
Photo by Chad Montano on Unsplash

California style pizza takes classic New York style crust and adds its own unique flair. It’s a culinary fusion that captures the essence of the West Coast cuisine through its choice of toppings.

Picture this: creamy avocados, crisp bean sprouts, peppery arugula, tender chicken, tangy goat cheese, and even a touch of tropical sweetness from pineapple. These are just a few examples of the exciting toppings you’ll find on a California style pizza. It’s a delightful combination of flavors and textures that also aims to offer a healthier approach to this beloved dish. With an emphasis on fresh, wholesome ingredients, it presents a guilt free option that still satisfies those pizza cravings. While you won’t likely find the healthies of healthy toping combinations at Seaside Heights pizza joints, you will find options that offer chicken and other healthier options.

Seaside Heights Pizza

In conclusion, the world of pizza is a rich tapestry of flavors, styles, and experiences. From the iconic New York and Chicago styles to the traditional Sicilian and the innovative California creations, each pizza brings its own unique charm to the table. There’s a pizza out there to satisfy every craving and ignite the taste buds.

As we explored various pizzerias in Seaside Heights and beyond, we discovered a treasure trove of culinary delights. From the longstanding favorites like Maruca’s and Three Brothers from Italy Pizza to the newer establishments like Little Mia’s.

Whether you’re seeking a traditional New York pizza or an authentic Sicilian, these pizzerias have you covered. From the quality of ingredients to the artistry of the crust, every aspect is carefully crafted to deliver a truly remarkable pizza experience.

So, the next time you find yourself looking for Seaside Heights pizza, we hope you are able to appreciate the passion and creativity that go into crafting these mouthwatering pies. Pizza is more than just a meal; it’s an experience that brings people together and creates lasting memories. So, grab a slice, share a laugh, and let the love for pizza continue to unite us all.